Hello, this is Adullam Consulting.
When an Indian subsidiary completes a tax audit and receives an assessment order, a penalty issue usually follows along with the additional tax. The question we hear most often from Korean headquarters at this point is: "Should we appeal and fight it to the end, or pay and close the matter?"
Until now, if the assessing officer found that income had been 'misreported', the options were narrow. The penalty was heavy at 200% of the tax, and the route of obtaining a penalty waiver in exchange for paying the tax and not appealing was closed. So most cases went to appeal.
The Finance Act, 2026 extended this route to misreporting cases, and on October 8, 2026 a new application form (Form 161) was notified. Today we summarise what has changed and what Korean companies facing transfer pricing adjustments should weigh.
- Under Indian income tax, the penalty for under-reporting is 50% of the tax, and the penalty for misreporting is 200% (Section 439 of the Income-tax Act, 2025).
- Under the Finance Act, 2026, misreporting cases can now also apply for a waiver of penalty and immunity from prosecution by paying additional income-tax. The additional income-tax is 100% for ordinary misreporting and 120% for cases of unexplained income.
- On October 8, 2026, the CBDT prescribed the new waiver application, Form 161, through Notification No. 134/2026 (Income-tax (Sixth Amendment) Rules, 2026).
- The application must be made within one month from the end of the month in which the assessment order is received, the tax and interest must be paid on time, and no appeal may be filed. If the application is accepted, the order cannot be appealed.
- The equivalent mechanism under the old Act (old Section 270AA) was also extended to misreporting from March 1, 2026, but interpretations still differ on how it applies to orders issued before that date.
1. What has changed — a 'waiver' route for misreporting too
Section 439 of the Income-tax Act sets the penalty for under-reporting at 50% of the tax, and at 200% where the under-reporting results from misreporting. The types of misreporting are listed in sub-section (11) of the same section. Section 440 provides that, if certain conditions are met, this penalty is waived and immunity from prosecution is granted. Previously it was available only for under-reporting; with this amendment it now extends to misreporting. In return, additional income-tax must be paid on top of the original tax and interest.
| Category | Penalty (Section 439) | Amount payable when applying for waiver (besides tax and interest) |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary under-reporting | 50% of the tax | No additional income-tax |
| Misreporting (Section 439(11)(a)–(f)) | 200% of the tax | 100% of the relevant tax |
| Misreporting involving unexplained income (sub-section (11)(g)) | 200% of the tax | 120% of the relevant tax |
The new Form 161 requires the PAN, the Document Identification Number (DIN) of the assessment order, the tax year, the assessed income and the under-reported income, and the amounts and payment details of tax, interest and additional income-tax. This notification does not waive penalties automatically; an application can be made only where the statutory conditions are met.
2. New Act or old Act — which applies to our case?
The new Income-tax Act came into force on April 1, 2026, but many of the assessment orders Indian subsidiaries are currently receiving relate to earlier periods (by assessment year). In such cases the provisions of the old Income-tax Act, 1961 may apply. The Finance Act, 2026 amended both Acts.
| Item | New Act Section 440 | Old Act Section 270AA |
|---|---|---|
| Effective date of extension to misreporting | April 1, 2026 (from tax year 2026-27) | March 1, 2026 |
| Additional income-tax | 100% (120% for unexplained income) | 100% |
| Main cases covered | Cases for tax year 2026-27 onward | Cases for earlier assessment years |
| Application deadline | One month from the end of the month the order is received | One month from the end of the month the order is received |
Because the amendment to old Section 270AA does not separately limit the assessment years covered, some take the view that it can be used for earlier-year cases as long as the application is made on or after March 1, 2026. However, there is still no official interpretation for cases where the order was issued before March 1 and the original payment deadline has already passed. A Bombay High Court ruling allowing a waiver in a misreporting case after the amendment has been reported, but it was a decision based on its specific facts. Please be sure to confirm with local chartered accountants and lawyers whether it applies to your case.
3. Conditions for the waiver application — the clock is one month
- Pay all tax and interest under the assessment order within the deadline stated in the notice of demand. In misreporting cases, pay the additional income-tax as well.
- Do not file an appeal against the assessment order (or the penalty).
- Apply to the assessing officer (AO) using Form 161 within one month from the end of the month in which the order is received.
- The assessing officer accepts or rejects the application within three months from the end of the month in which it is received. Before rejecting it, the officer must first give the taxpayer an opportunity to be heard.
If the application is accepted, no appeal or application for revision can be made against that assessment order. In other words, it is a choice to give up the right to contest in exchange for removing the penalty and prosecution risk.
4. For Korean companies — the calculation changes in transfer pricing cases
The adjustment that Indian Private Limited companies of Korean groups most often face concerns the pricing of transactions with headquarters, that is, transfer pricing. Section 439(11)(f) treats a failure to report an international transaction to which the transfer pricing provisions (Chapter X) apply as misreporting. If transactions with headquarters such as services, royalties or loans were left out of the report, a 200% penalty may be at issue, and waiver can now be considered in such cases as well.
The figures below are hypothetical, provided for illustration. Assume the tax on the under-reported income is ₹10 lakh. Tax and interest are payable in every case.
| Case | Penalty if the appeal is lost | Additional burden when applying for waiver |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary under-reporting | ₹5 lakh (50%) | ₹0 |
| Misreporting (e.g., failure to report) | ₹20 lakh (200%) | ₹10 lakh (100%) |
| Unexplained income | ₹20 lakh (200%) | ₹12 lakh (120%) |
On the numbers alone, applying for waiver looks cheaper, but the decision is not that simple. From the Korean headquarters' perspective, the following should also be considered.
- Whether the same issue will recur in following years: accepting this order may create an unfavourable precedent in the next year's assessment.
- The likelihood of winning on appeal: if the issue is a question of law, the expected benefit of appealing may be significant.
- Impact on the Korean side: how an adjustment finalised in India connects with Korean corporate tax, the foreign tax credit, or the mutual agreement procedure under the Korea–India tax treaty must be reviewed separately for each case.
- Decision-making time: the application deadline is short, so if headquarters' approval is delayed, the option itself disappears.
The table above is a hypothetical for explanation, and interest and cess calculations have been excluded. Actual amounts depend on the penalty provision cited in the assessment order (whether under-reporting, or which clause of misreporting). There are also few practical cases yet on how a waiver in a misreporting case affects other remedies beyond giving up the appeal.
5. From April 1, 2027 — assessment and penalty in a single order
The Finance Act, 2026 goes one step further. For assessment orders issued on or after April 1, 2027, the penalty will be levied within the assessment order itself rather than through separate proceedings. In addition, for those later orders, no interest will accrue on the penalty demand while the first appeal is pending. This means that, going forward, the 'appeal or waiver' decision must be made all at once the moment a single order is received.
What to do now
- Compile a list of ongoing audits and assessment orders.Summarise on one page the assessment year, issues, date of receipt of the order and the penalty provision cited. Also mark whether each is an old Act or new Act case.
- Set in advance the approval line for deciding within one month of receiving an order.Headquarters and the local team should agree beforehand on who decides, and when, on paying tax and interest and on whether to forgo an appeal.
- Check whether any international transactions are missing from the transfer pricing report.Confirming that services, royalties, loans and cost-sharing with headquarters have all been reported is the most reliable prevention.
- For old Act cases where orders have already been issued, confirm with experts whether the amendment applies.The starting point is whether the order date and payment deadline fall before or after March 1, 2026.
Frequently asked questions
No. All assessed tax and interest must be paid. What is waived is the Section 439 penalty and prosecution, and in misreporting cases additional income-tax is paid instead.
The law sets not appealing as a condition. Whether you can apply after withdrawing the appeal, and how the deadline is counted, may differ by case, so please confirm with local experts.
Form 161 is the application under new Act Section 440 pursuant to the Income-tax Rules, 2026. For cases under old Section 270AA, it is safer to confirm the application form and procedure separately with your chartered accountant.
Closing
With this amendment, misreporting cases now also have a route to 'pay additional income-tax and settle the penalty and prosecution risk'. However, because the application deadline is short and it involves giving up the right to contest, it is important to set decision criteria before receiving an order. Adullam Tax & Accounting organises the issues and cited provisions in assessment orders and, together with local experts, compares the pros and cons of appeal and waiver applications to support headquarters' decision-making.
Adullam Consulting is here to help.
Sources: News & e-Campaigns · Section 440 · CBDT Notifies Revised Income Tax Form No. 161 for Waiver of Penalty under Section 440 of Income-tax Act, 2025; Prescribes Additional Tax of 100% and 120% - A2Z Taxcorp LLP · Section 270AA Misreporting Immunity: Clarification Needed for Earlier Assessment Years · Bombay High Court Allows Section 270AA Penalty Waiver Despite Misreporting After Finance Act 2026 · Section 439 of Income-tax Act, 2025

Written by
Inae Lim
Adullam Corporation Co., Ltd. CEO
Helping Foreign Companies Enter and Operate in India
LinkedIn profile